9/25/07 10:20 pm - Lucia Di Lammermoor
Donizetti
Lucia Di Lammermoor
The Metropolitan Opera
Opening Night Gala, September 24, 2007
Natalie Dessay Marcello Giordani
James Levine
Opening night at the Met was quite the gala event, stars, evening gowns, tuxedos, and plenty of drama. The evening started off with the singing of the national anthem, Never has our national anthem sounded so beautiful, than last night. Of course, being in the Met, backed by the Metropolitan Opera Chorus, and surrounded by professional singers such as Placido Domingo and Anna Netrebko tends to help raise the quality of music just a bit. Peter Gelb came out to welcome everyone, and dedicate the performance to Beverly Sills and Pavarotti.
Act I
Enter James Levine, looking as excited as a school boy, he raised his baton and on went the performance. I was fearful of this new production, because one never knows how strange a new director will try to make it. I’ll pause here to say Brava Mary Zimmerman. This production was traditional, yet innovative. It was truly great.
The curtain opened to a very simple setting in the moors. The stage was partially covered in moss, with dark lighting that gave the place a mysterious air. After the first men’s chorus, Dessay entered dressed in what looked similar a to Victorian, black riding habit.
“Regnava nel silenzio” was gorgeous; as far as contemporary opera singers, Dessay’s wonderfully controlled pianissimos are second only to Renée Fleming’s. While Dessay was singing about this ghost tale, Zimmerman had a ghost actually seemed to float on stage, in an pale costume, with shadowy light. The second half of the aria was a completely different color, perfect for a young girl in love. I’ll stop here to say that the beauty of having Dessay play this role is that not only does she meet all the vocal challenges, but she looks the part to a fault. It is certainly believable that she is a frail young girl able to be driven mad by heart ache.
During this second, lighter half, Dessay began running around this small hill on stage, at which point she slipped and landed sitting on the stage floor. She played into it brilliantly as did Martens (playing Alisa). Dessay sang the next few bars sitting down and playfully got Martens to help her up, in character the whole time. Then she got up and finished the coloratura line effortlessly-amazing. The best was at the finish of the aria, during the applause, when she leaned against the side of the stage, out of character, laughing and fanning herself.
“Sulla tomba che rinserra” was perfection. Dessay’s voice was crystal clear and pin point focused, while Gioradani met every challenge. They blended beautifully and made the perfect couple in love. It received uproarious applause before the Intermission.
Act II
Act II began with another little blunder, right at the start of the act, causing the audience to laugh a bit. One of the draperies fell down, however, it didn’t make much difference in the overall affect of the setting because the rest of the furniture was draped in white cloth, so it blended right in. Dessay and Kwiecien acted well together as brother and sister. It was very believable and reminded me of the final scene in Eugene Onegin because of the realistic nature of the acting. At one point he actually threw her down to the floor. Her last note of the duet was perfect-powerful and faultlessly placed.
The set change for Scene II was interesting and also reminiscent of Onegin. Household servants entered and removed all of the draperies and cloths to reveal a large, green and gold ballroom.
The fact the Lucia had realized her fate was not difficult to observe because Dessay wore it all over her face. She really did do a great job with this character. Every scene one could see more of her sanity being stripped away. In this scene, Dessay wore a gorgeous red suit in contrast to the other cast members who wore gray and black. Zimmerman made a creative call by having the scene revolve around the taking of a family wedding photo after the wedding contract was signed. All of the characters are concentrating on looking pleasant for the photo, while Lucia stares blankly singing about her lost love and Edgardo paces, while singing of his betrayal by Lucia.
On to Intermission two; while mingling, I was lucky enough to spot Placido Domingo, Anna Netrebko and David Schwimmer. Netrebko looked gorgeous in a gold gown. I stood next to her for a while, shocked because she is one of those rare people that is much prettier in person than on tv.
Act III
If you hear the saying “save the best for last,” apply it to this opera because the mad scene is to die for, pun intended. The chorus was in top form, delivering a powerful, yet mournful refrain. “Orrida è questa notte” duet was superb. Giordani had some perfectly placed, powerful notes.
And now what you’ve all been waiting for...The Mad Scene. I was pleased to see that Zimmerman kept the traditional long staircase for Lucia to descend. However, I have a feeling no other Lucia has descended it so quickly; because Dessay ran so fast I thought she would trip again. The entire scene was riveting. Dessay kept most ever action subtle; no big outburst excepting one scream. After descending the stairs she lay on the third stare from the top rocking back and forth like a small child, while singing superb runs, then, suddenly, she rolled down the rest of the stairs to the floor. If you want to talk ping then please speak of Natalie Dessay last night. Ever tone was crystal clear and rang out through the hall. She later lay on the prompter’s box and sang with perfectly controlled crescendos and diminuendos. At one point I had occasion to count an 8-10 second trill, she never stopped amazing me. More subtle gestures were found throughout, accompanied by flawless singing. Such as when she kept spinning in a circle for a full minute or two, but never stopped singing. Dessay also stood on the stairs tearing up her veil and then proceeded to cradle it like a baby. The most outstanding, however washer full voiced coloratura at times and her whispers at others. Throughout the whole opera I only heard one slightly off note from Dessay and she, never the less made it work. The Scene ended when she fainted into the arms of 3 cast members leading everyone else on stage to freeze on the spot, while the men carried her slowly up the steps one at a time. At this point the audience went wild cheering. The opera stopped for a full 5 minutes to allow for the applause to die down.
Giordani did a good job with Scene II. This aria has so many high sustained lines, that he had to battle with, but it was impressive. While he was singing of dying, Dessay, dressed as a ghost glided on stage, immensely happy to be with him as he stabs himself. Curtain.
The audience once again went wild for bow after bow. Dessay entered for her bows by pretending to slip again, causing much laughter from the audience One can tell she has quite the sense of humor. After Dessay finished with her bows on stage she ran out to the balcony where I saw her taking bows for the crowd outside. The audience hadn’t had enough though, because they cheered her as she reentered the met foyer, where she stood and waved down at us.
So at the end of the evening the production was good (some say dreary, but I approve) and Natalie Dessay is a permanent star in the Met firmament. I’d see it again.






